Cutting competition : Is ICAP justified in barring non-ICAP people?

Attention: open in a new window. PDFPrintE-mail

Economic Updates - Exclusive Articles

While a current notification released through the Institute of Chartered An accounting firm of Pakistan (ICAP) barring member auditing firms from engaging students using their company validating physiques might have upset the country’s top anti-trust watchdog, most ICAP students appear happy concerning the decision that allegedly limits competition within the auditing profession.

“I think it can make absolute sense for ICAP to first accommodate its very own students within the institute’s member auditing firms,” stated one chartered accountancy student, who’s going through mandatory training in an accountants. “Trainees owned by ICAP at auditing firms happen to be in surplus,” he told , around the sidelines from the CA Students Conference 2012 held on Thursday.

Regarding the ICAP’s contentious directive released on This summer 4, your competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) released a show-cause notice to ICAP on September 17 asking the former’s reps to look within a week in Islamabad to describe the explanation behind the notification.

Talking with , ICAP Leader Rashid Rehman Mir stated ICAP would explain its position prior to the CCP on October 4, because the hearing scheduled for September 24 have been postponed.

“First of, it is really an internal matter. Next, the problem has already been in a quasi-judicial forum. Therefore, because of the sensitive character from the problem, I am unable to make any elaborate public statement at this time,” Mir stated.

Based on the CCP, ICAP’s directive forecloses use of a sizable segment from the relevant sell to students, and seems to stay in breach of Section 4 from the Competition Act, 2010.

The implementation from the ICAP directive could keep students from the Association of Chartered Licensed An accounting firm (ACCA), Institute of Chartered An accounting firm of Britain (ICAEW) and Chartered Institute of Management An accounting firm (CIMA) from auditing businesses that are people of ICAP.

Why restrict competition?

Students striving being chartered an accounting firm are needed to accomplish a minimum of 3 years of practical training in an auditing firm. This really is in comparison along with other accounting physiques, like the ACCA, that do not require their students to obtain working experience in a single particular area.

Consequently, students owned by different professional physiques operate in various fields, for example tax working as a consultant, auditing, banking along with other financial services, while ICAP students spend their mandatory training period at audit companies only.

Oddly enough, industry sources state that salaries of fresh chartered an accounting firm within the auditing area are less than individuals in working as a consultant and financial services with a margin of 20% to 30%.

Performs this imply that ICAP’s policy of restricting its students to auditing firms throughout their mandatory training period is really keeping them from more profitable jobs? Furthermore, will barring member auditing firms from engaging students of other professional physiques lead to further power of ICAP students inside the auditing profession?

“While it is a fact that salaries of chartered an accounting firm are greater in non-auditing jobs, it’s wrong to visualize that ICAP’s policy limits the choices of ICAP students,” stated another ICAP student.

He states that employed by an auditing firm provides a student a properly-rounded contact with a myriad of companies. “Getting training in a bank is only going to introduce students towards the banking sector. But in an auditing firm, you can study a few things about all industries besides working on your knowledge of an area,” he stated.

Within an interview with in Feb, the ICAP leader had stated that roughly 20% of ICAP people have typically labored in auditing firms, which figure was shedding due to ‘stringent regulations’ which frustrated fresh ICAP graduates from entering public practice.

Forex open Market rates & comments Archive

Login Form